Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$13.50
White Pizza
With fresh garlic & oil.
$13.00
Square Pizza Siciliana
Classic cheese on a Sicilian crust.
$19.00
Gourmet Pizza
Vegetarian Pizza
With onions, mushrooms, green peppers & black olives.
$16.00
Meat Lovers Pizza
Pepperoni, bacon, ham, sausage & meatballs.
$16.00
Hawaiian Pizza
Pineapple & ham.
$15.00
Prospero Pizza
Pepperoni, sausage, onions & jalapeno.
$16.00
Works Pizza
Pepperoni, black olives, sausage, onions, green peppers & mushrooms.
$16.00
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
With chicken breast, bleu cheese & hot sauce.
$17.00
BBQ Chicken Pizza
With BBQ sauce, mozzarella & grilled chicken.
$17.00
Chicken Alfredo Pizza
With mozzarella cheese, alfredo sauce & chicken.
$17.00
Ranchero Pizza
With bacon, jalapeno, onions & chicken.
$17.00
White Spinach Pizza
Mozzarella cheese, ricotta, spinach, fresh tomatoes, fresh garlic & olive oil.
$17.00
White Broccoli Pizza
Mozzarella cheese, ricotta, broccoli, fresh tomatoes, fresh garlic & olive oil.
$17.00
Margherita Pizza
Pizza sauce, fresh mozzarella & fresh basil.
$16.00
Cheesesteak Pizza
Mozzarella cheese, American cheese & onions.
$17.00
Stuffed Pizza
With pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, ricotta & mozzarella cheese & spinach.
$24.00
Pizza by the Slice
Cheese Pizza Slice
$3.00
Specials
Two Large Cheese Pizzas & 2 Liter Drink Special
$29.50
Three Topping Large Pizza Special
$19.50
Large Cheese Pizza & 20 wings special
$39.50
Two Medium Cheese Pizzas Special
$22.50
Large Cheese Pizza & 10 Wings Special
$28.50
Large Cheese Pizza & Loaded French Fries Special
$22.50
Two Large Cheese Pizzas, 20 Wings & 2 Liter Drink Special
$51.00
Small Cheesesteak, Fries & Drink Special
$12.50
Two Pizza Slices & Can of Drink Special
$6.00
Small Meatball Parm, Fries & Drink Special
$10.00
Cheeseburger, Fries & Can of Drink Special
$10.00
Gyro, Fries & Can of Drink Special
$10.00
Wrap, Fries & Can of Drink Special
$11.00
Appetizers
Wings
Deep-fried chicken wings with your choice of sauce.
$15.00
Boneless Wings
Boneless chicken breast coated in breading.
$12.00
Breaded Wings
Chicken wings coated in breading.
$16.00
French Fries
Our delicious French fries are deep fried 'till golden brown, with a crunchy exterior and a light fluffy interior. Seasoned to perfection!
$5.00
Old Bay Fries
Spiral potatoes seasoned with Old Bay (celery, salt, black pepper, crushed red pepper flakes, and paprika).
$5.50
Cheese Fries
Melted cheese over our delicious fries.
$6.00
Loaded Fries
With ranch.
$11.00
Mozzarella Sticks
Deep fried cheese sticks. Crispy on the outside, gooey on the inside. Virtually guaranteed to be a table favorite! Served with a side of marinara sauce.
$8.50
Onion Rings
Crispy onion slices deep-fried until golden-brown.
$8.00
Jalapeno Poppers
With ranch.
$8.50
Breaded Mushrooms
Fresh hand-breaded mushrooms, deep fried to a golden brown color.
$8.00
Chicken Fingers
Breaded and fried chicken strips.
$10.50
Buffalo Chicken Fingers
$11.00
Garlic Bread with Cheese
A cross between garlic bread and pizza, cheesy bread is a quick, easy, and delicious party snack.
$5.50
Cheese Bread Sticks
Deep fried cheese sticks. Crispy on the outside, gooey on the inside. Virtually guaranteed to be a table favorite! Served with a side of marinara sauce.
$8.50
Shrimp Basket
Deliciously battered and fried butterfly shrimp.
$10.50
Cinnamon Bites
$7.00
Broccoli Bites
Fried broccoli with grated onions, mayonnaise, cheese, lemon zest, salt & pepper.
$9.00
Chicken Quesadilla
Chicken, onions, green peppers, and mozzarella cheese with a side of sour cream & salsa.
$11.00
Pizza Fries
Topped with pizza sauce and mozzarella cheese.
$9.50
Nachos
With chili, cheddar cheese, jalapenos, lettuce, tomatoes, sour cream & taco sauce.
$9.00
Chicken Finger Platter
Chicken fingers and french fries.
$13.00
Soups
New England Clam Chowder Soup
Clams, diced potatoes, onions, and celery.
$7.00
Chili
$6.00
Fresh Salads
Garden Salad
Mixed lettuce, spring mix with tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, green peppers, kalamata olives, mozzarella cheese, boiled egg & croutons.
$9.00
Chicken Salad
Mixed lettuce, spring mix with tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, green peppers, kalamata olives, mozzarella cheese, boiled egg & croutons.
$12.00
Turkey Salad
Turkey, mozzarella cheese on mixed lettuce with tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, green peppers, kalamata olives, boiled egg & croutons.
$12.00
Tuna Salad
Tuna, mozzarella cheese on mixed lettuce with tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, green peppers, kalamata olives, boiled egg & croutons.
$12.00
Chef Salad
Imported ham, roast beef, oven-roasted turkey, provolone cheese on mixed lettuce with tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, green peppers, kalamata olives, boiled egg & croutons.
$12.00
Antipasto Salad
Imported ham, genoa salami, capicola, provolone cheese, on mixed lettuce with tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, green peppers, kalamata olives, pepperoncini, boiled egg & croutons.
$12.00
Greek Salad
Feta cheese with mixed lettuce with tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, kalamata olives, pepperoncini & croutons.
$11.00
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce with parmesan & croutons.
$8.00
Chicken Caesar Salad
Grilled chicken on romaine lettuce, with parmesan cheese & croutons.
$11.00
Grilled Chicken Salad
Grilled chicken, mozzarella cheese on mixed lettuce with tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, green peppers, kalamata olives & croutons.
$12.00
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Grilled chicken, buffalo hot sauce on mixed lettuce with tomatoes, onions, green peppers, kalamata olives, mozzarella & croutons.
$12.00
Mediterranean Salad
Grilled chicken, feta cheese on mixed lettuce with tomatoes, kalamata olives & croutons.
$12.00
Cobb Salad
Grilled chicken on mixed lettuce with tomatoes, boiled egg, gorgonzola cheese & bacon.
$12.00
prospero's salad
Grilled chicken,shrimp,mozzarella cheese 0n mixed,lettuce with tomatoes,cucumbers,onions, green peppers,kalamata olives and croutons
$15.00
Chips
Herr's Crisp 'N Tasty Chips
$2.75
Herr's Kettle Cooked Chips
$2.75
Herr's Kettle Cooked Jalapeno Chips
$2.75
Herr's Kettle Cooked Sour Cream & Onion Chips
$2.75
Herr's Kettle Cooked Salt & Vinegar Chips
$2.75
Herr's Red Hot Chips
$2.75
Herr's Ripples Chips
$2.75
Herr's Sour Cream & Onion Chips
$2.75
Herr's Barbeque Chips
$2.75
Herr’s Cheese Curls Chips
$2.75
Stromboli
Cheese Stromboli
pizza sauce & mozzarella cheese
$12.00
Pepperoni Stromboli
Pepperoni mozzarella cheese & pizza sauce
$15.00
Meat Lovers Stromboli
pizza sauce mozzarella cheese w/ Pepperoni bacon, ham, sausage, meatballs.
$15.00
Italian Stromboli
pizza sauce mozzarella cheese w/ Ham, salami & capicola.
$15.00
Sausage Stromboli
pizza sauce mozzarella cheese w/ Green peppers, onions, sweet peppers & mushrooms.
$15.00
Meatball Stromboli
pizza sauce mozzarella cheese w/ Green peppers, onions, sweet peppers & mushrooms.
$15.00
Steak Stromboli
pizza sauce mozzarella cheese w/ Green peppers, onions, sweet peppers & mushrooms.
$15.00
Chicken Stromboli
pizza sauce mozzarella cheese w/ Green peppers, onions, sweet peppers & mushrooms.
$15.00
Buffalo Chicken Stromboli
Buffalo sauce, mozzarella, grilled chicken & side of bleu cheese.
$15.00
Veggie Stromboli
pizza sauce mozzarella cheese w/ Green peppers, onions, sweet peppers, broccoli & mushrooms.
$14.00
Hamburger Stromboli
pizza sauce mozzarella cheese w/ Fried onions, green pepper, sweet pepper & mushrooms.
$15.00
Calzones
Cheese Calzone
Mozzarella cheese, ricotta & side of marinara sauce. Additional toppings for an additional cost.
$12.00
Rolls
Pepperoni Roll
Pepperoni mozzarella cheese w/ side of marinara sauce
$10.00
Sausage Roll
Italian sausage green peppers onions hot peppers mozzarella cheese w/ side of marinara sauce
$10.00
Spinach Roll
Spinach mozzarella ricotta cheese w/ side of marinar sauce
$10.00
Chicken & Broccoli Roll
Chicken broccoli mozzarella cheese w/ side of marinara sauce
$10.00
Cold Sandwiches
Ham Sandwich
$7.00
Cheese Sandwich
$7.00
BLT Sandwich
Classic bacon, lettuce and tomato sandwich.
$7.00
Roast Beef Cold Sandwich
$7.00
Tuna Sandwich
$7.00
Turkey Sandwich
$7.00
Italian Sandwich
Ham, salami, capicola, onions, sweet peppers, and cheese.
$7.00
Chicken Salad Sandwich
$7.00
Hot Sandwiches
Tuna Melt Sandwich
A delicious combination of tuna and melted cheese on toasted bread.
$7.00
Turkey Melt Sandwich
$7.00
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Delicious grilled chicken sandwich topped with cheese.
$7.00
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Creamy grilled cheese sandwich.
$7.00
Grilled & Ham Cheese Sandwich
Classic ham & cheese sandwich.
$7.00
Grilled Cheese & Bacon Sandwich
$7.00
Chicken Filet Sandwich
$7.00
Flounder Sandwich
$7.00
Subs
Italian Sub
Peppers, ham, genoa salami & capicola.
$11.00
Imported Ham Sub
Topped with deli-sliced ham.
$11.00
Roast Beef Sub
Juicy roast beef with your choice of fixings.
$11.00
Turkey Sub
Turkey and veggies make for a scrumptious sub.
$11.00
Veggie Sub
$9.00
Cheese Sub
$9.00
Tuna Sub
Delicious tuna fish salad & veggies in a satisfying sub.
$11.00
Chicken Salad Sub
Served with lettuce, tomatoes, provolone, and mayo.
$11.00
Clubs
Turkey Club
Freshly made with cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise, layered between toasted bread.
$11.00
Tuna Club
$11.00
Ham Club
$11.00
Roasted Beef Club
$11.00
Grilled Chicken Club
$11.00
BLT Club
Crisp bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise.
$11.00
Chicken Salad Club
Served with lettuce, tomatoes, provolone, and mayo.
$11.00
Parmigiana Subs
Chicken Parm Sub
Chicken, parmesan, and classic cheese.
$11.00
Meatball Sub
Topped with homemade meatballs and classic cheese.
$11.00
Sausage Parm Sub
Fried onions, green peppers & mushrooms.
$11.00
Steaks
Plain Steak
A killer sub packed with succulent steak.
$9.00
Cheese Steak
Shredded steak topped with classic cheese.
$11.00
Chicken Cheese Steak
Shredded chicken steak cooked on melt American cheese
$11.00
Chicken Caesar Steak
Romaine lettuce, parmesan & caesar dressing.
$11.00
Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak
Served with cheese, bleu cheese, and hot sauce.
$11.00
Pizza Steak
Marinara sauce & provolone cheese.
$11.00
Cheese Burger Sub
The flavors of your favorite cheeseburger, in sub form!
$11.00
Philly Steak
Fried onions, cheddar cheese, green peppers & mushrooms.
$11.00
Burgers
Cheeseburger
$6.50
Bacon Cheeseburger
Delicious cheeseburger topped with fresh crispy bacon.
$7.50
Hamburger
$6.00
Pizza Burger
Marinara sauce & mozzarella.
$7.00
Steak House Burger
Steak sauce, bacon, American, provolone & swiss cheese.
$7.50
Tex Mex Burger
Barbecue sauce, cheddar cheese & jalapeno.
$7.50
Wraps
Italian Wrap
Lettuce, tomatoes, onions and melted cheese.
$12.00
Ham Wrap
$12.00
Roast Beef Wrap
$12.00
Turkey Wrap
Turkey, lettuce, tomatoes and onions.
$12.00
Veggie Wrap
Lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and melted cheese.
$12.00
Cheese Wrap
$12.00
Tuna Wrap
Lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and melted cheese.
$12.00
Chicken Salad Wrap
Served with lettuce, tomatoes, provolone, and mayo.
$12.00
Cheese Steak Wrap
Thin-sliced meat with cheese, onions, green peppers, lettuce, and tomatoes.
$12.00
Chicken Cheese Steak Wrap
Shredded chicken steak cooked with onions, green peppers, mushrooms, lettuce and tomatoes.
$12.00
Chicken Caesar Steak Wrap
Romaine lettuce, parmesan & caesar dressing.
$12.00
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Crispy chicken breast strips with a buffalo sauce, cheese, lettuce and red onion in a soft, toasted tortilla wrap.
$12.00
Panini
Italian Panini
Fresh mozzarella, basil, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, hot peppers & light mayo.
$12.00
Chicken Panini
Grilled chicken, provolone, roasted peppers, bacon & honey mustard.
$12.00
Philly Steak Panini
Cheddar, fried onions, mushrooms & green peppers.
$12.00
Turkey Panini
Provolone cheese, mayo, lettuce, tomato & onion.
$12.00
Roast Beef Panini
Provolone cheese, lite mayo, fried onions, mushrooms & roasted peppers.
$12.00
Gyros
Gyro
With cucumber sauce, lettuce, tomatoes & onions. Served with fries.
$10.00
Chicken Gyro
With honey mustard sauce, lettuce, tomatoes, onions & fries.
$10.00
Pasta Dishes
Chicken Parmigiana Entree
Served with a dinner roll.
$15.00
Fettuccine Alfredo
Fettuccine tossed in our creamy homemade alfredo sauce.
$12.00
Spaghetti with Meatballs
Spaghetti topped in our homemade meatballs.
$14.00
Lasagna
Lasagna topped with classic cheese, tomato sauce, and ground beef.
$15.00
Cheese Ravioli
Ravioli stuffed with classic cheese.
$13.00
Manicotti
A large tube of fresh pasta stuffed with a blend of soft cheese.
$12.00
Stuffed Shells
Classic ricotta stuffed shells with flavorful three cheese ricotta filling and delicious marinara sauce.
$14.00
Baked Ziti
Ziti with mozzarella and tomato sauce baked to perfection in our oven.
$12.00
Kids Menu
Kid's Chicken Tenders
With fries.
$7.50
Kid's Grilled Cheese
With fries.
$6.00
Kid's Spaghetti with Meatballs
Spaghetti topped in our homemade meatballs.
$7.50
Kid's Cheese Ravioli
Ravioli stuffed with classic cheese.
$7.50
Desserts
Double Chocolate Cake
Fluffy and golden-brown on the outside, warm and melty Oreo on the inside!
$5.50
Carrot Cake
Moist cake, spiced with cinnamon and frosted with cream cheese frosting.
$5.50
Tiramisu
A delicious coffee-flavored italian dessert. Ladyfingers dipped in coffee, layered with a whipped mixture of eggs, sugar & Mascarpone cheese, flavored with cocoa.
$5.50
Strawberry Cheese Cake
Classic cheesecake with a rich, dense, smooth, and creamy consistency topped with delicious strawberry.
$4.50
Cannoli
Delicious tube of fried dough, filled with a sweet, creamy ricotta filling.
$3.50
Beverages
Soda
Nothing like a cold soda to go with your pizza.
$1.25
Brisk Iced Tea
So refreshing!
$1.25
Brisk Lemonade
$2.75
Gatorade
$3.00
Pure Leaf Iced Tea
So refreshing!
$2.75
Water
$1.25
Fresh Salads Catering
Garden Salad Catering
Mixed lettuce, spring mix with tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, green peppers, kalamata olives, mozzarella cheese, boiled egg & croutons.
$28.00
Caesar Salad Catering
Romaine lettuce with parmesan & croutons.
$28.00
Grilled Chicken Salad Catering
Grilled chicken, mozzarella cheese on mixed lettuce with tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, green peppers, kalamata olives & croutons.
$38.00
Chef Salad Catering
Imported ham, roast beef, oven-roasted turkey, provolone cheese on mixed lettuce with tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, green peppers, kalamata olives, boiled egg & croutons.
$38.00
Chicken Caesar Salad Catering
Grilled chicken on romaine lettuce, with parmesan cheese & croutons.
$38.00
Mediterranean Salad Catering
Grilled chicken, feta cheese on mixed lettuce with tomatoes, kalamata olives & croutons.
$38.00
Greek Salad Catering
Feta cheese with mixed lettuce with tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, kalamata olives, pepperoncini & croutons.
$38.00
Antipasto Salad Catering
Imported ham, genoa salami, capicola, provolone cheese, on mixed lettuce with tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, green peppers, kalamata olives, pepperoncini, boiled egg & croutons.
$38.00
Sub & Wrap Trays Catering
Sub Tray Catering
5 subs, your choice of meat, with lettuce, tomatoes, provolone cheese & olive oil.
$58.00
Wrap Tray Catering
8 wraps, your choice of meat, with lettuce, tomatoes, provolone cheese & mayo.
$58.00
Prospero's Pizza
Enjoy New Castle's best pizzas at some of the top pizza restaurants in the area. Prospero's Pizza is one of the most popular in New Castle. Try their pizza, and you'll soon see why. Try some of New Castle's best dishes at independent pizzerias in the city. Find new favorites and get a taste of what New Castle has to offer. You can't say you've been to Prospero's Pizza until you've tried Cheese Pizza. This classic local favorite is what this establishment is known for. Add french fries to your pizza for a more satisfying meal. It's a great addition to any pizza from Prospero's Pizza. Prospero's Pizza has been a Slice partner since 2021. They've been serving the local community for a while now, so you can rely on them providing great pizza. Call ahead and get curbside pickup at Prospero's Pizza. It's never been easier to get hot, fresh pizza to go. You can also try Prospero's Pizza's other locations. There's sure to be one near you. You can pay by credit card at Prospero's Pizza. That makes it easy to get your pizza as quickly as possible.
Full Hours